What To Say When An Interviewer Calls You At A Bad TimeJewel Bracy DeMaioon February 23, 2022 at 4:30 pm Work It Daily


It finally happens! The phone rings and, being in active job search mode, you eagerly answer every unrecognized number because it could be your next employer. But at the particular moment, you’re at the gym, in line at the grocery store, or picking up your kids from after-school sports.

When the phone rings in these situations, it can be mentally jarring, and therefore difficult to focus. Not to mention you’re unlikely to have your resume or other notes in front of you about the particular company. (You did take notes on your company research, right?) So, resist the urge to proceed with the phone interview anyway, out of fear that you won’t get another chance. You will, as long as you set the proper tone of this initial conversation with the recruiter.

Here’s what to say when an interviewer calls at a bad time:

Answer The Phone Correctly

Since most jobs are going to require that you speak to some other human being inside or outside the company, it’s important to demonstrate how you would answer the phone in professional circumstances.

The first impression you give the interviewer should be an indication of the first impression you would give to that company’s vendors or customers. Eliminate the awkward five seconds when the recruiter, probably thinking it’s you, is required to ask for you, only for you to respond with, “Who’s calling?” (or the more defensive version, “Who’s this?”). The wrong inflection can make you seem like you’re avoiding bill collectors, and the entire exchange slows the flow of conversation. Instead, smile—yes, smile through the phone (people can tell!)—then announce your name.

A simple, “Hello. This is Joe,” will immediately confirm to the recruiter they’ve reached the right person and set the stage for a pleasant exchange.

Express Gratitude And Enthusiasm

Over the phone, your voice, tone, and attitude are the sole criteria available to the recruiter in these initial moments. This is the opportunity you were waiting for, so be happy about it. Regardless of the busy scenario you’re caught up in, if you had a second to answer the phone, then you have a second to ensure your tone is positive.

Continue to build on your pleasant-sounding foundation. Say, “Thanks so much for calling. I was hoping I’d hear from you. I’ve been really excited about this opportunity since I first came across it.”

Speak The Truth (Or Something Like It)

Clarify that you can’t talk right now, but don’t overshare. When you call someone at work who can’t speak right now, their administrative assistant says, “She’s in a meeting at the present moment,” regardless of what the case actually is because it really doesn’t matter. Maintain the same level of professionalism—no need to say you’re two minutes from completing your 10-minute mile on the treadmill. Your objective is to politely and firmly end the current call.

Demonstrate your professionalism and initiative by setting up the next call. It’s like a date. When you ask someone out, if the response is, “No, I can’t,” then you have to wonder if that means no forever or just no to that particular day. Either way, not a good feeling. But if the response is, “I can’t on Tuesday. How about Thursday?” then you have something definite to go on. Apply the same concept to the conversation with the recruiter. Say, “I need to be in a quieter place in order to focus. May I return your call in one hour?”

Phone interviews can be nerve-wracking, especially when you’re caught off guard. The next time an interviewer calls you at a bad time, remember these three things. You’ll be sure to leave a great first impression and successfully avoid an awkward phone call.

Want to find a job that won’t burn you out? Sign up for Work It Daily’s new FREE course “Break Through Your Burnout: How To Go From Crisis To Career Satisfaction.”

In this FREE course, you will discover:

Where you currently fall on the Career Satisfaction Spectrum and how it impacts your ability to make good career choicesHow your unique combination of personality, skills, and preferences directly impacts what types of careers you are a good fit forWhy choosing an employer to work for should feel like a fun shopping experienceWhat you can do to leverage the knowledge above to find a new, better job—or make the job you are in feel much more satisfyingInterested? Sign up today! It’s time to take back your happiness.Work It Daily

Leave a Comment